Diffusion Of Ehr Innovation

No affair what your see of Electronic Health Records (EHR) is, you lot would in all probability handgrip that the concept of computerizing medical records represents an invention of sorts. The spread of innovation, or its diffusion, has been researched together with modeled past times Rogers[1] equally a bell shaped advancement through populations of Innovators, Early Adopters, Early Majority, Late Majority together with Laggards (the bluish bend inwards the figure below). At to a greater extent than or less quest during this spread of an innovative solution a Critical Mass of adopters, or Tipping Point, is reached together with the invention is assured widespread diffusion (Gladwell[2]).  Adoption is unremarkably described past times an S-shaped bend of adopters vs. time, together with the charge per unit of measurement of adoption is the gradient of the S-shaped bend at whatever given fourth dimension (the cherry-red bend inwards the figure).

The Tipping Point occurs correct afterwards the charge per unit of measurement of adoption assumes its largest value which volition live on maintained throughout most of the adoption process. It is worth noting that the diffusion of invention model is non predictive. Many innovations linger together with expire inside the Innovator circle. Another of import aspect of the model is that the fourth dimension variable is non constrained. Depending on the charge per unit of measurement of adoption, it may bring weeks, months or many years for an Innovation to spread throughout a given population. There is no enquiry that EHR adoption is slow moving upward on the ascending side of a classic diffusion model bell curve, only is it moving fast enough? Is the tipping quest visible? Are nosotros at that topographic point yet?

In companionship to respond these questions together with assess where nosotros are on the path to EHR adoption, nosotros must examine the elements affecting diffusion of novel ideas, objects or practices, i.e. Innovations, equally they pertain to EHRs.

The Innovation – Not all things classified equally Innovations are equal together with this may explicate why to a greater extent than or less succeed inwards becoming primary flow together with others fail. Rogers[1] suggests 4 defining characteristics of innovation:

• Relative Advantage – To what flat is the EHR perceived to live on meliorate than the exercise it aims to supersede – newspaper charts? The daily debates on the merits of EHR inwards diverse wellness assist forums are stark testimony to the fact that potential users are sharply divided on the respond to this question. For some, EHRs are increasing efficiency together with improving character of assist for patients. For others, EHRs are impediments to character of assist together with an endless coin pit for the practice. The biggest advertised wages of EHRs, interoperability, is niggling to a greater extent than than a promissory annotation issued past times EHR proponents to prospective adopters. The Government is adding an wages inwards the cast of stimulus incentives together with time to come fiscal penalties for non-adoption. This wages seems to live on meaning for hospitals together with large groups, only less together with so for modest private practices.
• Compatibility – Are EHRs compatible with existing values, past times experiences together with needs of potential adopters? Here EHRs are existence propelled onto the much larger phase of wellness assist reform. They are no longer a humble replacement of pen & newspaper together with fax machines. EHRs are instruments of change; a alter from treating 1 patient at a fourth dimension the best you lot can, to considering value-based strategies for the create goodness of entire populations, together with considering those correct at the quest of care. This seems to live on a major divergence from a value organisation created together with enriched across many generations of medical doctors.
• Complexity – Simplicity is ever a virtue. The complexity of infirmary EHRs, with their unwieldy CPOE modules, has created a perception of EHRs existence stiff together with unduly complicated tools, which bring years to master.  The uncomplicated ambulatory EHRs available today, get got failed to alter these perceptions. To live on fair, EHRs are inherently to a greater extent than complex than a slice of paper, only that should non necessarily deter adoption. After all, the bicycle was to a greater extent than complex than walking, together with making burn downward was extremely difficult initially.
• Trialability – Experimenting with modest parts of an invention earlier taking the terminal leap reduces adopters’ adventure together with anxiety. EHRs tin post away be, together with to a greater extent than oft than non are, implemented inwards stages, especially inwards hospitals. In the ambulatory sector at that topographic point was a tendency to implement electronic prescribing equally a lawsuit earlier consummate computerization. Perhaps the best exercise of Trialability for EHRs is the gratuitous trials offered past times equally good few vendors.
• Observability – An invention is to a greater extent than probable to live on adopted if its results are easily visible to others. This of course of study assumes that the results are positive. Unfortunately, successful implementations of EHRs are uneventful together with largely anonymous, piece their failing counterparts, unremarkably associated with astronomic losses inwards funds together with sometimes lives, are real visible, heavily advertised together with frankly to a greater extent than interesting. There is no tidings inwards a iii physician exercise inwards Omaha installing a mid-priced EHR together with having no problems to report.

Communication Channels – The tidings together with evaluation of an invention are spread throughout the community past times diverse means, from volume media to informal peer to peer communications. As every EHR vendor knows, the latter is the most prevalent together with effective method of disseminating messages alongside physicians. It is also a real dull method of creating awareness together with unless the invention is indisputably positive, much confusion is created past times conflicting messages from friends together with colleagues, thence slowing downward the diffusion process. The Government’s intervention, with all its glorious publicity together with billions of dollars inwards back upward of the innovation, is doing wonders inwards bypassing the conventional “word of mouth” diffusion mechanism. The downside is that EHR is straight off associated with Big Government together with a detail flavour of politics.

Time – Time is involved inwards diffusion of invention inwards several ways.

• On an private flat the innovation–decision procedure goes through 5 stages known as: noesis – persuasion – determination – implementation – confirmation. In EHR manufacture parlance, these interpret to: enquiry – assessment – selection – implementation – adoption. The shorter the innovation-decision private bicycle is together with the to a greater extent than people genuinely consummate it without dropping out inwards its midst together with the to a greater extent than positive their adoption sense is, the faster an invention is expected to diffuse. For EHRs this bicycle tin post away make anywhere betwixt a few months for a modest exercise to several years for a large hospital. The Government imposed Meaningful Use schedules are shortening the innovation-decision bicycle for those racing to qualify for maximum incentive. Perversely, the inadequate fourth dimension allowed for implementation volition also growth failure rates together with adverse events, which does non bode good for long term diffusion rates.
• Diffusion is also affected past times the Innovativeness of the population targeted past times the innovation. Here is where nosotros run into the accusations of physician existence inherently opposed to technological advancements, together with the counter arguments based on the number of iPhones together with iPads already owned past times physicians, non to lift all the advanced technologies inwards imaging, surgical operation together with other medical fields, which are readily embraced past times the medical community. When it comes to EHRs though, most docs don’t hear existence real tardily adopters or fifty-fifty laggards.
• The charge per unit of measurement of adoption dictates how much fourth dimension it volition bring for an invention to diffuse throughout the system. Unfortunately for EHRs, the charge per unit of measurement of adoption is heavily theme on the 5 characteristics of an invention together with none of those are especially stellar for EHRs. This is why the charge per unit of measurement of EHR adoption prior to HITECH has been lingering at the bottom of a real broad S-curve. The Government intervention, which equally mentioned inwards a higher house is increasing the fiscal advantage, is making a marked difference inwards the charge per unit of measurement of adoption effectively pushing EHRs upward the S-curve.

The Context – Innovations are diffused inside the boundaries of a social system. The structure, norms together with leadership of a organisation also touching the diffusion of innovations.  Systems whose members are similar inwards education, social condition together with beliefs (homophilous) are non good suited to rapid alter together with innovation. Physicians arguably create cast such system. The historical depression rates of EHR adoption could live on attributed to lack of accepted see leaders inwards general, together with those who see EHRs equally a positive invention inwards particular. The world personas that get got an MD afterwards their scream together with relentlessly advocate for EHR adoption are unremarkably non practicing physicians together with equally such, are non accepted equally respected see leaders past times most practicing doctors.

The diffusion patterns described together with so far are assuming that the invention is optional for whatever given individual. However, innovations are non ever an private choice. Sometimes the determination to nowadays is Authority Driven. Authority driven innovations are faster to live on adopted together with depending on the flat of coercion, may follow a completely unlike path. Up to HITECH, private physicians inwards private exercise considered EHRs optional. Those employed past times hospitals or large groups were experiencing the effects of potency driven invention all along, thence the much larger adoption rates inwards those sectors. Although EHRs are non silent mandatory, the increasing pressure level exerted past times Government incentives, regulations together with penalties is changing the diffusion patterns of the EHR innovation.

Keep inwards hear that Government exertions create non remove to maintain until every physician inwards the province has purchased an EHR. They exclusively remove to ensure a critical volume of EHR adopters is created together with the mythical Tipping Point is reached. The Tipping Point is unremarkably observed at almost 15% adoption nether normal circumstances together with is marked past times the emergence of see leaders who adopted the Innovation. EHRs together with wellness assist inwards full general are anything only normal together with I would human face a larger per centum of adoption to live on required earlier EHRs “take off” inwards a self-sustaining fashion. As to respected see leaders, at that topographic point are none.

So are nosotros at that topographic point yet? I don’t recollect so, only nosotros are awfully close.
__________________________________________________
1. Everett M. Rogers (1995), Diffusion of Innovations (Fourth Edition), New York, Free Press.
2. Malcolm Gladwell (2000), The Tipping Point: How Little Things Can Make a Big Difference, New York, Little Brown.