Rationing Our Finite Resources… Amongst Our Eyes Open

Two articles published inwards the latest NEJM number are devoted to “our finite resources” as well as the inevitability of rationing care. First Dr. Howard Brody is attempting to rephrase the number equally i of “waste avoidance” as well as is delving into the ethics of practicing waste matter avoidance which is defined equally withholding non-beneficial care. Of course of report non beneficial is non a cutting as well as dry out label, thus Dr. Brody is envisioning that “[a]n ethical organisation for eliminating waste matter volition include a robust appeals process”, where “[p]hysicians, equally loyal patient advocates, must invoke the procedure when (according to their best clinical judgment) a detail patient would do goodness from an intervention fifty-fifty if the average patient won't”. While the sentiment is commendable, I am non clear who just should physicians appeal to “according to their best clinical judgment” as well as I am non sure where the newly empowered as well as engaged patient go. Or is all this empowerment as well as appointment utter only a savage joke?

The minute article inwards NEJM, which is authored past times M. Gregg Bloche, M.D., J.D. as well as titled “Beyond the “R Word”? Medicine's New Frugality”, is argument that it is rattling unlikely that nosotros could genuinely cutting the waste, which is estimated at 30% of costs, as well as fifty-fifty if nosotros do, costs volition proceed to ascension as well as nosotros are only postponing the inevitable. The inevitable, inwards the form doctor’s opinion, is denying beneficial care. No beating around the bush whatever longer. Just say it as well as do it. Of course, the empowered patients are nowhere to hold out establish inwards this article either, although it is amount of advice for politicians on how to decease nigh stopping therapeutic advances inwards their tracks, because “we can't afford all the things that medicine tin achieve” as well as “we must brand painful choices betwixt wellness attention as well as other needs”. Sadly Dr. Bloche J.D. did non elaborate on his “other needs”.

But the most disturbing sense for me was reading the comments posted to both articles, to a greater extent than often than non past times physicians, as well as to a greater extent than often than non supportive of the quest to ration attention to patients. One physician commenter inwards detail seemed to run into rationing equally “a logical corollary of our responsibilities equally physicians” because physicians are citizens earlier they decease physicians as well as they accept duties as well as responsibilities to their beau citizens which “are non superceded [sic] past times the mythical primacy of the doctor-patient relationship”.
Well, if nosotros must ration our finite resources, let’s ration them with our eyes open, equally Dr. Berwick wisely stated. So hither is some oculus opening fabric for your rationing pleasure….
                                                   **********************

Random Non-profit Hospital Quotes

“Millions of dollars accept been spent transforming the infirmary into a beautiful, soothing, healing environment. Artwork graces the walls as well as soft music fills the hallways. ……..
“Hospital food” is also out-of-the-ordinary at Fauquier Health; The Bistro on the Hill provides nutrient options for patients as well as their guests. Earning a reputation of its ain inwards Warrenton, the Bistro serves everything from brick-oven pizza to gourmet pasta, from a fresh soup as well as salad bar to shrimp stir-fry. Bakers hold the dessert illustration filled with fresh cakes as well as pies, cookies as well as tarts. Community groups often congregate at The Bistro, as well as catering for off-site events is available.” http://www.fauquierhealth.org/about-us

“A six-story pavilion is nether construction on the due west side of Missouri Baptist Medical Center. The patient tower is purpose of a major edifice projection that also volition run into construction of a novel Clinical Learning Institute, novel entry way, parking lot as well as nature trails for the campus at 3015 N. Ballas Road. The West Pavilion volition add together 216,000 foursquare feet to the medical centre as well as volition household the medical center's novel primary entrance lobby; 4 floors of somebody patient rooms for surgical patients; 4 novel operating rooms; as well as a novel outpatient surgical operation centre that volition connect to the hospital's electrical flow operating room suites. "Medicine has changed a lot since 1965 (when Missouri Baptist relocated to its introduce location), when patient rooms were smaller as well as they withal genuinely had patient wards," said Jesse Arevallo, facility as well as campus planning director. "The novel criterion of attention requires a larger edifice footprint," he said. "This project, creating state-of-the fine art equipment as well as facilities, volition tremendously do goodness patients as well as the community." The somebody infirmary rooms volition allow the medical centre to discovery a novel utilisation for its semi-private rooms inwards the primary purpose of the hospital. "So we're non genuinely adding beds, but replacing," Arevallo said. The West Pavilion volition toll $140 million. It is slated for completion past times July 2013.” http://www.stltoday.com/suburban-journals/metro/news/missouri-baptist-medical-center-to-add-six-story-patient-tower/article_7efd4ea4-fdcd-538d-abc5-cbc464d531f6.html

“Patient-centered amenities abound inwards the novel Cancer Center facility
As patients as well as families move inwards the foyer of the Cancer Center facility, they volition stair into a cozy, living room-style infinite with fireplace, sofas, chairs as well as decorative carpeting. Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 nearby café volition offering indoor as well as outdoor seating as well as a health-focused carte du jour with fruits as well as vegetables from local farmers. ……  Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 focal betoken of the edifice is a central, five-story, light-filled atrium, which looks downwards on spiraling artwork filled with inspirational quotes from Duke cancer patients as well as friends.” http://construction.dukemedicine.org/projects 20 

Highest Paid Non-Profit Hospitals CEOs inwards the Midwest

1. Randall O’Donnell; Children’s Mercy Hospital as well as Clinics; Kansas City, Missouri: $6 million
2. Javon Bea; Mercy Health System; Janesville, Wisconsin: $4.5 million
3. James Skogsbergh; Advocate Health Care; Oak Brook, Illinois: $4 million
4. Dean Harrison; Northwestern Memorial Hospital; Chicago, Illinois: $3.4 million
5. Richard Pettingill; Allina Health System; Minneapolis, Minnesota: $3.3 million
6. Joseph Swedish; Trinity Health; Novi, Michigan: $2.7 million
7. Lowell Kruse; Heartland Regional Medical Center; St. Joseph, Missouri: $2.5 million
8. Steven Lipstein; BJC Health System; St. Louis, Missouri: $2.2 million
9. Kevin Schoeplein; OSF Healthcare System; Peoria, Illinois: $2.2 million
10. Thomas Sieber; Genesis Healthcare System; Zanesville, Ohio: $2.1 million
11. Paul Pawlak; Silver Cross Hospital; Joliet, Illinois: $2 million
12. Toby Cosgrove; Cleveland Clinic; Cleveland, Ohio: $1.9 million
13. William Petasnick; Froedtert Memorial Hospital; Milwaukee, Wisconsin: $1.9 million
14. Fred Manchur; Kettering Medical Center; Dayton, Ohio: $1.9 million
15. Patrick Magnon; Children’s Memorial Hospital; Chicago, Illinois: $1.8 million
16. Kenneth Hanover; University Hospital; Cincinnati, Ohio: $1.8 million
17. J. Luke McGuinness; Central Dupage Hospital; Winfield, Illinois: $1.8 million
18. Daniel Evans Jr.; Clarian Health Partners; Indianapolis, Indiana: $1.8 million
19. James Madera; University of Chicago Medical Center; Chicago, Illinois: $1.8 million
20. James Anderson; Cincinnati Children’s Hospital Medical Center; Cincinnati, Ohio: $1.8 million
http://medcitynews.com/2011/08/nonprofit-hospital-ceo-salaries-in-the-midwest-whos-on-top/

2009 Insurance Companies Total CEO Compensation

• Aetna, Ronald A. Williams: $18,058,162
• Coventry, Allen Wise: $17,427,789 (took over from Dale Wolf)
• WellPoint, Angela Braly: $13,108,198
• United Health, Stephen Helmsley: $8,901,916
• Cigna, David Cordoni: $6,593,921 (took over from CEO H. Edward Hanway)
• Cigna, H. Edward Hanway: $18,800,000
• Humana, Michael McCallister: 6,509,452
• Health Net, Jay Gellert: $3,643,342
http://www.healthreformwatch.com/2011/03/16/health-insurance-ceo-total-compensation-in-2009/ 

                                                   **********************
Following Dr. Brody’s reasoning, I tin surely run into some golden opportunities hither for ethical waste matter avoidance, with a proper appeals procedure inwards place, of course. And equally painful equally it may be, some of the beneficial ambiance provided past times fireplaces, freshly baked brioche as well as well-fed executives volition quest to hold out cutting equally well, because Dr. Bloche is largely right as well as nosotros do accept other needs, which could hold out addressed past times having corporations, whose cash flows allow for millions of dollars inwards existent estate investments as well as executive compensation, pay their taxes first.

If you lot intend that this is a liberal overreaction to a twosome of academic papers, intend again. In the January 2010 issue of NEJM, Dr. Brody suggested that each specialty should pick a “Top Five” listing of expensive tests as well as treatments that should hold out discouraged. Today nosotros accept the ABIM Choosing Wisely drive of just 5 “don’ts” for each specialty. What I discovery fascinating is that routine EKGs, for example, are discouraged twice inwards the ABIM lists, but places similar the top ranked Mount Sinai hospital seem to intend that having those routine EKGs as well as much to a greater extent than is a rattling practiced thought (if you lot accept $6,000) as well as volition “help you lot as well as your associates alive longer, healthier lives through the highest measures of preventive care”. So is Mount Sinai with its “award-winning physicians” correct? Or is ABIM correct? Or do nosotros advocate ii standards of attention based on the size of your wallet?

As to Dr. Bloche J.D., his Huffington Post bio, suggests that with his many degrees as well as honors he “was a wellness attention advisor to President Obama’s 2008 campaign, equally good equally the presidential transition, as well as he spoke often for the drive equally a “surrogate.””.  Is he speaking equally a “surrogate” (whatever that may be) when suggesting that nosotros must ration beneficial attention (Mount Sinai executive customers excluded, of course)?

I don’t accept the answers to these questions, but the implications to non-policy makers are pretty clear. To all the ePatients, participatory patients, engaged as well as empowered patients out there, I would propose that you lot devote equally much fourth dimension to budding policies equally you lot do to obtaining access to your electronic data, because having existent fourth dimension visibility into how your attention is beingness denied volition render rattling footling comfort, fifty-fifty if it is supplied to you lot inwards a computable as well as transferable structured information format.
To all practicing doctors, if you lot passively allow yourselves to hold out represented past times learned articles similar the ones cited hither because you lot are likewise busy seeing patients, the solar daytime volition come upwardly when, inwards the eyes of the public,  your profession volition hold out no different than that of an IRS auditor, including fiscal as well as social rewards. Yes, you lot volition most probable retire past times then, but this is the Medicine you lot are going to sense inwards your quondam age, as well as this is the Medicine you lot are bequeathing to your children as well as grandchildren, as well as this is non the Medicine that was entrusted to you lot past times previous generations of physicians.